Wednesday, April 24, 2024

It's money, not conservation, at play here

| November 30, 2021 7:00 AM

If there is one thing we can depend on, it is Michael Garrity and the Alliance for the Wild Rockies litigating another forest restoration project proposed by the U.S. Forest Service. This time Mr. Garrity wants to stop the Ripley Project, which is in the Kootenai National Forest and adjacent to the community of Libby.

This 29,000-acre project was developed following the disastrous 2017 wildfire season that destroyed over 200,000 acres of the Kootenai National Forest. Included in those conflagrations was the West Fork Fire, which threatened residential areas north of Libby, prompting evacuations and burning tens of thousands of acres of privately-owned forest lands.

In an effort to protect the community from further risks of wildfire, the Forest Service, Lincoln County, the Kootenai Valley Stakeholders, Montana DNRC, and other private landowners joined forces to develop the Ripley Project to protect the community and provide restoration services for other resources including wildlife and water.

It seems the safety of people living in and near Libby and other resource values aren’t important to Mr. Garrity, although he professes in his lawsuit that grizzly bears and Canada lynx aren’t getting the protections they deserve. What Mr. Garrity is really hoping for is that he can find a chink in the 322-page environmental analysis prepared by the Forest Service and approved by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service in the hopes that a judge will rule that the project analysis was inadequate.

The real endgame for Mr. Garrity is that — if the court rules in his favor — his organization might receive attorney’s fees for filing the lawsuit under the Federal Equal Access to Justice Act (EAJA). On large lawsuits such as Ripley, which will often be heard by the courts two or three times, a successful award could be in the range of several hundred thousands of dollars.

With this understanding of how EAJA works, it doesn’t take a lot of imagination to understand that Mr. Garrity’s business model involves suing the Forest Service, since he has multiple lawsuits currently under way in Montana and Idaho. He has filed lawsuits on multiple national forests, including the Nez Perce-Clearwater, Idaho Panhandle, Kootenai, Lolo, Helena-Lewis and Clark, and Custer Gallatin.

There is no risk to filing the lawsuit because there is no penalty or payment owed to the Forest Service should the litigation fail, only an upside benefit of attorney’s fees if he wins.

Local residents know all to well the precarious situation we are in concerning the wildfire potential throughout Lincoln County. Each year we worry about our safety until we see fall rains and snowfall.

The next time you read about a lawsuit filed by Mr. Garrity and the Alliance for the Wild Rockies, don’t focus on his false claims that he his trying to save the last grizzly bear or Canada lynx. Look a little deeper and understand that he is trying to pad his pocketbook with another big award from the Forest Service and U.S. taxpayers.

In the case of the Ripley Project, should he be successful, the community of Libby will remain at extreme risk of wildfire while Mr. Garrity takes the money that could have been used to thin those acres to prevent further destruction and possible loss of life.

Greg Larson